Home

Advertisement

Customise
About this Journal
This is [info]baratron's journal to track internet frauds I've personally witnessed - to provide information and examples for the online community to learn from. I'd like to hope that it's a journal I'll never have to update, but recent events seem to be proving otherwise. Please link to this journal and spread the cynicism!
Links:
Why internet fraud sucks and why I created a journal about it. What is an internet fraud? Munchausen by Internet and other links. A Beginner's Guide to Faking Your Death On The Internet (video).
Current Month
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728
1st Feb, 2007 @ 00:58 Case 4: M's fake internet death.
The story: A woman called M, who was previously a popular moderator on a web forum, posted to tell people she had personal problems to take care of and wouldn't be on the site as much as usual. Then suddenly a few days after that her husband posted to say she had committed suicide.

Status: FAKE

More details: People were very upset by M's death, what with it being so sudden, and with her leaving behind an estranged husband and 2 kids. Apparently she died of an overdose. Her "husband" posted on the forum using first a new account that he made, followed by a post from her account, using her password, which she'd left in a text file on the computer "just in case".

Read more... )
About this Entry
1st Feb, 2007 @ 00:29 Case 3: X's dying nephew.
The story: A woman called X had a 16 year old nephew who had cancer. He'd been seriously ill and received a present from the Make A Wish Foundation, then the cancer had gone into remission for a few years, then it had returned. She was angry and upset with the unfairness of the world that he was dying so young and wanted a little support from her friends.

Status: TRUE

More details: I'm telling this story here so you can compare and contrast it with J's dying baby. Unfortunately, X fell victim to the effect whereby a community, having had one faker, gets all twitchy about anyone else who's asking for help.

Read more... )
About this Entry
1st Feb, 2007 @ 00:11 Case 2: D, the woman who never existed.
The story: A 26 year old woman and single mother called D had a very dramatic life. Over a period of mere months, she lost her boyfriend in a car accident, had a car accident herself, discovered she had breast cancer, and finally died in a possible suicide, or an accidental overdose.

Status: FAKE

More details: It turns out that D never existed, and that she was the invention of her 16 year old "brother".

When D "died" in August, her "brother" posted to let people know. Apparently, D "kept a txt file in her My Documents folder containing her passwords in case of anything like this." Hmmm. Some people were suspicious of this death, coming so soon after J's fake baby, and they asked me to do a little digging.

Read more... )
About this Entry
31st Jan, 2007 @ 23:39 Case 1: J's dying baby.
The story: A woman called J claimed she was pregnant. Her husband was in the Army and had recently been posted overseas. She went into premature labour and was rushed to the hospital. The baby was born - at 26 weeks gestation, with a mass of 880g. He was in the neonatal intensive care unit, quite probably unlikely to make it.

Status: FAKE.

More details: This was the first internet fraud that I was personally involved with. I suppose I need to "thank" J for getting me interested in this topic, such as it is. Blah.

Round about April 2006, I started going to a couple of new irc channels, where I met a woman called J. A few days after I joined the channel, J said that she was pregnant and showed us some blurry ultrasound pictures. She was very excited about the pregnancy and talked about it incessantly - to the point I asked if this would be her first baby. She said "My third - but the other two are no longer with us". That was a vague enough statement that I specifically asked if that meant they'd gone to live with her ex, and was told that they were no longer alive. Over the next few weeks, I wondered why, if she had lost two babies before, she was so excited about this pregnancy to the point of showing ultrasound scans to people on the channel, buying things for the child and choosing names. My existing knowledge of people who've lost babies is that they would be very wary of the new pregnancy, not counting any chickens until they'd hatched - and any joy would be tempered with grief. However, I didn't like to pry, and I figured that the other babies must have been early miscarriages, and she was past that stage in this pregnancy, therefore everything was okay. Read more... )
About this Entry
31st Jan, 2007 @ 22:47 Why internet fraud sucks and why I created a journal about it.
I have a generally high opinion of human nature. I believe that people in general are good. Most of us feel a sense of kinship to others in our tribe, however we choose to define that - people in our birth or adopted families, people who live in our town, people who share common interests. Looking out for each other & looking after each other is something we can do that takes very little energy - because if everyone is doing it, the burden is shared.

Some people abuse that basic human goodness with lies and frauds of various kinds. That makes me angry in itself. What's even worse is when a community, having had one faker, gets all twitchy about anyone else who's asking for help. It's like the boy who cried wolf. People are then afraid to be nice to others and send them the good wishes they need, for fear that their story is another fraud like the last one, meaning that some real people end up being disbelieved. A person in distress should not feel that they have to provide corroborating evidence that their situation is genuine :/

That's why I publicise these fake internet babies, illnesses and deaths. To warn you to be suspicious, and check all the details - especially before spending time on the person or sending gifts for them. But you don't have to become so cynical you distrust everyone - in fact, I'd argue that's what a lot of the internet fakers want. They don't have enough friends, so they want no one to have friends. If you stop caring for people and trusting them, the sociopaths win.
About this Entry
31st Jan, 2007 @ 21:44 Munchausen by Internet.
So, the majority of internet frauds I'm going to be talking about here are ones where people tell lies to their online communities, possibly going as far as to fake their own deaths. I have no idea what would make people do this, though Dr Marc Feldman has proposed they suffer from a condition called Munchausen by internet. I can provide you with any number of links about Munchausen by Internet:

Sympathy-Seekers Invade Internet Support Groups from www.healthyplace.com. This two-page article includes two sets of "diagnostic criteria" that you can use to test your "friend's" stories.

Cybersickness: Munchausen by Internet Breeds a Generation of Fakers by Francine Russo,
June 27 - July 3, 2001, from the Village Voice. See also Wired News: They Think They Feel Your Pain by Jenn Shreve, 06 Jun 2001, from Wired.

A Strange Case of Munchausen by Internet. Discusses the use of sockpuppets, extra fake accounts that support the original poster's story. You will note their use in some of the Cases that follow.

Kaycee Nicole Swenson didn't just have a fake internet death: her entire life was fake. The short life of Kaycee Nicole by Bobbie Johnson, Monday 28 May 2001, from the Guardian. More about Kaycee Nicole from the New York Times: A Beautiful Life, an Early Death, a Fraud Exposed by Katie Hafner, 31 May 2001. See also The Life and Death of a False Warrior by shirobara of kuro5hin.org, Tue 22 May 2001. Snopes.com has an article Several authors of inspiring books and web logs have turned out to be fictitious featuring both Kaycee Nicole Swenson and Tony Godby Johnson.

If all of that is too depressing for you, I suggest viewing the video A Beginner's Guide to Faking Your Death On The Internet by http://lukelewis.net. He also discusses the insanity ratio of the online community in question, the "Camwhore factor", and the use of sockpuppets. It's very funny, even if parts of the video make you cringe.
About this Entry
31st Jan, 2007 @ 20:17 What is an internet fraud?
What do I mean by an internet "fraud"? Well, there's a bunch of different types. I suppose I see three different levels:

The lowest level is the kind of fraud that doesn't even need the internet. Things like selling an item on eBay that turns out to be very much not as described. For example, they say it's a "brand new"/"unused" iPod they got as an "unwanted Christmas present". The buyer receives it, and it turns out to be a 2 year old iPod that doesn't work properly and is thoroughly out of warranty. I say this doesn't need the internet because an unscrupulous person could just as easily pull this off through newspaper or magazine small ads.

The internet works both ways with these kinds of frauds. On the one hand, it's easy to hide behind a bunch of different "seller" IDs to hide your dubious dealings. The fact that you can receive money through PayPal or other online transfer services without giving your real postal address really helps in this. And whenever eBay suspends one of your IDs for dodginess, you can just set up another. On the other hand, large corporations like eBay and PayPal do have Buyer Protection Policies, and it is occasionally possible to get a full or almost-full refund from them when sellers mess you about.

The highest level is the kind of fraud involving thousands of UK pounds or US dollars. These are things along the lines of "Nigerian" scams or 419 scams, when a person sends out bulk, unsolicited email claiming they will give someone a large sum of money in return for a small service. This is major crime that can cause victims to lose many thousands of pounds or dollars, destroy credit ratings and even lose their homes. Nowadays, I receive "Nigerian" scam email at my personal domain several times a week, and it seems the scammers aren't just restricting themselves to locations in developing countries - an American acquaintance received a "Nigerian" spam from a scammer claiming to be in the UK.

It's obvious why these major frauds are a problem, I think - anything where people lose large sums of money is a bad thing. Fortunately, the police and secret services of various countries are alert to them, and will prosecute if enough information can be obtained to track down the scammer. Unfortunately, that's a helluva big "if".

In the middle are scams of social engineering. These most commonly involve members of an online community telling lies to other members of that community; making increasingly outrageous claims for sympathy, attention or even financial reward. In my opinion, these are actually the worst kind of internet frauds, because they involve people who are supposedly your friends. Many people who consider themselves far too savvy to be taken in by a "give me $10,000 to receive $1 million later"-type scam will fall for "omg, my cat's sick and I need to find $1000 for the bill"-type scam, because while you don't trust some complete random who emails you out of the blue, you do trust your friend that you've been chatting to online for a couple of months. I consider these fake internet deathers as absolutely sick. I'll talk about why in my next post.
About this Entry

Advertisement

Customise